59 BANK Reviews
 

Litchfield County Times Monthly

A New Milford Addition

By Abigail Leab Martin
Staff Reporter

     With its high ceiling of patterned tin, expansive brick walls and gleaming woodwork, the new restaurant 59 BANK features "a Soho atmosphere at a New Milford price," in the words of co-owner and chef Arthur Michaelsen, Jr.

     He and his staff have revamped the former Kaleidoscope on Bank Street in New Milford into a warm, welcoming and polished space.

     And what a space it is.  The downstairs, which previously could have been described as cavernous, has instead been made cozy yet airy with the repainting of the walls to a pale, cheerful yellow and the addition of the brightening accent of large flowers - both as part of a tapestry covering one wall and in an elaborate floral arrangement situated in a colorful urn.

     Upstairs, the focus of the restaurant is wood - from the large, burnished bar to the luminous floor, well offset by the subtle, attractive lighting.  It is obvious that a great deal of care and thought has gone into redesigning this space.

     That's hardly a surprise, given the years of experience that Mr. Michaelsen has in the restaurant business.  About 16 years ago, Mr. Michaelsen and his wife, Julia, 59 BANK's other co-owner, had a successful eight-year run with Heibeck's Ice Cream in Georgetown, CT.

     That achievement was followed by the next restaurant endeavor, Ridgefield's 33 & 1/3, which Mr. Michaelsen ran with his sister Nancy Burke, and his mother, Josie Connelly.  The latter establishment's popularity also explains his current spot's choice of name.  "Numbers work well for us and we have a successful trend with them," Mr. Michaelsen explained.

     The boldness of the renovation and the warmth of the atmosphere of 59 BANK are very much an echo of the chef's personality.  The Culinary Institute of America graduate is bursting with energy, enthusiasm and creativity.

     And his plans are manifold.  Mr. Michaelsen has already instituted a weekday happy hour from 4 pm to 6 pm that offers tempting and tasty items such as buffalo chicken nuggets and fruit and cheese crudites.

     He has also created an extensive brunch menu that includes several tantalizing crepes and a variety of elaborate egg options.

     Along with rounding up more musical acts to feature on Friday and Saturday nights, Mr. Michaelsen also noted that other forms of entertainment were also under consideration, such as an open microphone night on Wednesday and a karaoke night on Thursday.

     Amid that backdrop, Mr. Michaelsen is striving to establish a restaurant that will please the palates of a broad range of guests, from the most discerning gourmet to an everyday bar food fan.

     "We're going to try to meet everybody's needs as far as what they'd like," the chef explained.  To that extent, he is even soliciting comments on a form included with the check.  "This is something that we have always done," he said.  "I think the only way to run it (the restaurant) is to respond to the feedback."

     Attempting such broad appeal can be daring and tricky.  The result so far is a qualified success.

     Certain dishes on the menu are as flavorful and innovative as any seasoned gourmet could hope for.  The flatbreads, delicate, crispy grilled pizzas laden with a variety of toppings, are flat out fabulous.  The veggie version may be Mr. Michaelsen's most delicious creation, with its generous mix of broccoli, zucchini, roasted peppers, sauteed spinach and mozzarella, finished off with a generous crumbling of goat cheese.

     The blending of colors and textures also makes for a dining experience that is most pleasing to several senses simultaneously.  The classic featuring pepperoni is also quite savory.  In fact, any of the nine versions of flatbreads that 59 BANK offers would make an ideal lunchtime takeout treat.

     Salads are also an area in which 59 BANK excels.  The best of a delectable array is the Banker's Cobb.  A melange of colors, textures and flavors, the salad incorporates tomato, hardboiled egg, red onion and grilled chicken, but it is the tang of Maytag blue cheese, the crunch of crispy bacon and the subtle flavors of slivers of fresh avocado that elevate this dish into something sublime.  And the size of the salad is so generous that it can easily satisfy the hungriest customer over the course of two meals.

     Other dishes are a little more hit and miss, though the misses are just by a whisker.  For example, the baked bowtie al forno begins delightfully with a coating of lightly browned mozzarella topping noodles that are perfectly cooked to be soft and yielding rather than limp and soggy or overly chewy.  Delving below the mozzarella, the mixture of parmesan and ricotta cheese combined with caramelized onion and herb breadcrumbs is pleasing and light.  But the sudden appearance of indelicate chunks of chicken seemed somehow incongruous, almost like an afterthought.  Their removal would greatly improve an otherwise enjoyable dish.

     However, it should be noted that 59 BANK has only been open since Columbus Day and that many a restaurant undergoes an initial period of adjustment before hitting its stride.  59 BANK is getting very close and what it does well, such as the flatbreads and the salads, it does very well indeed.

     In addition, the combination of prices and serving sizes makes 59 BANK an attractive dining option - and with approximately 59 items on the dinner menu, plus specials, there is certainly something there to tempt everyone.

     Seductively ample portions are the norm and the prices are such a party of four could have a satisfying meal for $100.  Appetizers range in price from about $3.59 to about $9, while entrees run from $6.59 for a burger to $14.59 for a 16-ounce ribeye steak.

     Desserts are in the $6 range, and the wine list offers plenty of good choices for less than $30.

     As Mr. Michaelsen noted with gratitude, so far New Milford's response has been overwhelmingly favorable.  59 BANK does not seem to be able to keep take-out menus in stock and the weekends have seen the restaurant bustling with business.  "I think the most rewarding thing is that on Saturday night we had a wave of people waiting to sit down and eat dinner.  That was very exciting," said the chef with a smile.
 

 
 
59 Bank Street New Milford, CT 06776 | (860) 350 5995 FAX: (860) 350 3511